Case Summary
| Case ID | 24F-H051-REL |
|---|---|
| Agency | ADRE |
| Tribunal | OAH |
| Decision Date | 2025-07-18 |
| Administrative Law Judge | Samuel Fox |
| Outcome | full |
| Filing Fees Refunded | $500.00 |
| Civil Penalties | $0.00 |
Parties & Counsel
| Petitioner | Michele Beauchamp | Counsel | — |
|---|---|---|---|
| Respondent | The Villages at Rio Paseo Condominium Association | Counsel | Beth Mulcahy, Esq. |
Alleged Violations
ARS 33-1213, ARS 33-1242, ARS 33-1248, ARS 33-1258
Outcome Summary
Petitioner was deemed the prevailing party regarding the alleged code of conduct violation because the code was not properly enacted when the violation occurred. The Respondent was ordered to refund the $500.00 filing fee and comply with community documents going forward.
Key Issues & Findings
Petitioner's alleged violation of the Respondent’s code of conducted based on Petitioner’s conduct at a board meeting on December 14, 2020
Whether the violation and associated fine issued to the Petitioner based on her conduct at a December 14, 2020 board meeting were proper, given that the code of conduct governing the violation was not properly enacted at that time.
Orders: Respondent ordered to pay Petitioner the filing fee of $500.00 and directed to comply with the requirements of its Community Documents going forward.
Filing fee: $500.00, Fee refunded: Yes
Disposition: petitioner_win
Cited:
- 32-2199
- 32-2199.01
- 32-2199.02
- 41-1092.09
- 33-1213
- 33-1242
- 33-1248
- 33-1258
Analytics Highlights
Additional Citations:
- 32-2199
- 32-2199.01
- 32-2199.02
- 33-1213
- 33-1242
- 33-1248
- 33-1258
- 41-1092.09
Decision Documents
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1189617.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1192167.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1192172.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1192173.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1192174.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1192175.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1192176.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1192177.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1192178.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1192179.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1192180.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1192181.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1192182.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1192183.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1192184.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1192185.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1192186.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1192187.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1192188.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1192189.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1192190.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1192191.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1192192.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1192193.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1192194.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1192195.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1192196.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1192197.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1192198.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1192199.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1192200.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1192202.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1192203.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1192204.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1192205.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1192206.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1192207.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1192209.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1192210.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1192211.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1192214.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1192215.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1192216.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1192219.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1192220.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1192221.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1192222.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1192223.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1192224.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1192225.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1192226.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1192227.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1192228.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1192230.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1192231.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1192232.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1192233.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1192234.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1192235.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1192236.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1192237.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1192238.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1192239.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1192241.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1192242.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1192243.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1192246.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1192247.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1192248.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1192250.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1192251.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1192252.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1192254.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1192255.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1192256.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1192257.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1192258.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1192259.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1192260.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1192261.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1192262.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1192263.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1192264.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1192265.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1192266.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1192268.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1192269.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1192270.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1192271.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1192273.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1192274_part_001.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1192275.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1192276.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1192277.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1192278.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1192279.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1192280_part_001.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1192281_part_001.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1192282.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1192283.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1192284.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1192285.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1192286.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1192308.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1192309.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1192310.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1192311.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1192317.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1192318.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1192320.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1192321.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1205546.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1205998.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1209327.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1209328.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1209329.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1209332.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1209333.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1209334.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1209335.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1209336.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1209337.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1209338.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1209339.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1209340.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1209341.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1209342.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1209345.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1209346.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1209347.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1209348.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1209349.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1209350.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1209351.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1209352.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1209353.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1209355.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1209356.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1209357.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1209358.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1209361.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1209362.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1209363.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1209365.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1209366.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1209367.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1209368.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1209369.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1209370.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1209372.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1209373.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1209374.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1209375.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1209376.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1209377.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1209378.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1209379.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1209380.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1209381.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1209383.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1209384.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1209385.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1209386.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1209387.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1209388.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1209389.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1209390.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1209391.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1209392.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1209393.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1209394.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1209395.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1209396.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1209397.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1209413.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1209414.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1209415.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1209416.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1209417.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1209418.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1209420.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1238387.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1277266.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1277274.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1287179.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1287181.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1308714.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1315077.pdf
24F-H051-REL Decision – 1330177.pdf
Facebook Comments Box
