Category Archives: Associations

Performance summaries for HOA and condominium associations

Pmpe Community Association Inc

Posted on by

Pmpe Community Association Inc appears in 3 ADRE/OAH disputes.
Homeowners prevailed in 1 matters while the association secured
1 wins, leaving 1 split decisions. Explore the
statutes, representation, and outcomes below.

Total Cases3
Issues Litigated3
Homeowner Issue Wins1
Association Issue Wins1
Homeowner Win Rate50.0%
Dominant RoleRespondent
Respondent Appearances3
Petitioner Filings0
Last Decision2022-03-30
Penalties AssessedNone
Avg Penalty / CaseNone
Filing Fees Recorded$1,000

Key Statutes & Violations

  • A.R.S. § 33-1817 (2 cases)
  • N/A (1 cases)
  • AR Section 4.4 (1 cases)
  • AR Section 1.1 (1 cases)
  • AR Section 4.2 (1 cases)

Representation Snapshot

When Defending Complaints

Top Law Firms

  • CHDB Law LLP — 2 cases

Lead Attorneys

  • Nicholas C. S. Nogami — 2 cases
  • Nichols C. Hogami — 1 cases

When Filing as Petitioner

No petitioner firm data recorded.

Case Volume by Year

Year Cases
2019 1
2021 1
2022 1

Case Explorer







    Cross Creek Ranch Community Association

    Posted on by

    Cross Creek Ranch Community Association appears in 2 ADRE/OAH disputes.
    Homeowners prevailed in 1 matters while the association secured
    1 wins, leaving 0 split decisions. Explore the
    statutes, representation, and outcomes below.

    Total Cases2
    Issues Litigated2
    Homeowner Issue Wins1
    Association Issue Wins1
    Homeowner Win Rate50.0%
    Dominant RoleRespondent
    Respondent Appearances1
    Petitioner Filings1
    Last Decision2024-12-16
    Penalties AssessedNone
    Avg Penalty / CaseNone
    Filing Fees Recorded$1,000

    Key Statutes & Violations

    • A.R.S. § 33-1804 (1 cases)
    • A.R.S. §§ 33-1804 / 33-1248 (1 cases)
    • CC&Rss Article 3 3.1.3 (1 cases)
    • Article 7 7.5 (1 cases)

    Representation Snapshot

    When Defending Complaints

    Top Law Firms

    • CHDB Law LLP — 1 cases

    Lead Attorneys

    • Nicholas Eicher — 1 cases

    When Filing as Petitioner

    No petitioner firm data recorded.

    Case Volume by Year

    Year Cases
    2022 1
    2024 1

    Case Explorer







      Solera Chandler Homeowners Association Inc

      Posted on by

      Solera Chandler Homeowners Association Inc appears in 2 ADRE/OAH disputes.
      Homeowners prevailed in 1 matters while the association secured
      1 wins, leaving 0 split decisions. Explore the
      statutes, representation, and outcomes below.

      Total Cases2
      Issues Litigated2
      Homeowner Issue Wins1
      Association Issue Wins1
      Homeowner Win Rate50.0%
      Dominant RoleRespondent
      Respondent Appearances2
      Petitioner Filings0
      Last Decision2021-03-17
      Penalties AssessedNone
      Avg Penalty / CaseNone
      Filing Fees Recorded$500

      Key Statutes & Violations

      • CC&Rs Article 9 9.5 (1 cases)
      • CC&Rs Article 7 7.1 (1 cases)
      • A.R.S. § 10-3821 (1 cases)
      • A.R.S. § 33-1804 (1 cases)
      • A.R.S. §§ 33-1804 / 33-1248 (1 cases)

      Representation Snapshot

      When Defending Complaints

      Top Law Firms

      • CHDB Law LLP — 2 cases

      Lead Attorneys

      • Lydia Peirce Linsmeier — 2 cases

      When Filing as Petitioner

      No petitioner firm data recorded.

      Case Volume by Year

      Year Cases
      2021 2

      Case Explorer







        Carter Ranch Homeowners Association

        Posted on by

        Carter Ranch Homeowners Association appears in 2 ADRE/OAH disputes.
        Homeowners prevailed in 1 matters while the association secured
        1 wins, leaving 0 split decisions. Explore the
        statutes, representation, and outcomes below.

        Total Cases2
        Issues Litigated2
        Homeowner Issue Wins1
        Association Issue Wins1
        Homeowner Win Rate50.0%
        Dominant RoleRespondent
        Respondent Appearances2
        Petitioner Filings0
        Last Decision2020-01-30
        Penalties AssessedNone
        Avg Penalty / CaseNone
        Filing Fees Recorded$500

        Key Statutes & Violations

        • A.R.S. § 33-1813 (1 cases)
        • A.R.S. § 33-1804 (1 cases)
        • A.R.S. §§ 33-1804 / 33-1248 (1 cases)
        • A.R.S. § 33-1808 (1 cases)

        Representation Snapshot

        When Defending Complaints

        Top Law Firms

        • Maxwell & Morgan, P.C. — 1 cases
        • Shaw & Lines LLC — 1 cases

        Lead Attorneys

        • Chad M. Gallacher — 1 cases
        • Augustus H. Shaw IV — 1 cases

        When Filing as Petitioner

        No petitioner firm data recorded.

        Case Volume by Year

        Year Cases
        2018 1
        2020 1

        Case Explorer







          Vve Casa Grande Homeowners Association

          Posted on by

          Vve Casa Grande Homeowners Association appears in 1 ADRE/OAH disputes.
          Homeowners prevailed in 1 matters while the association secured
          0 wins, leaving 0 split decisions. Explore the
          statutes, representation, and outcomes below.

          Total Cases1
          Issues Litigated1
          Homeowner Issue Wins1
          Association Issue Wins0
          Homeowner Win Rate100.0%
          Dominant RoleRespondent
          Respondent Appearances1
          Petitioner Filings0
          Last Decision2020-05-21
          Penalties AssessedNone
          Avg Penalty / CaseNone
          Filing Fees Recorded$500

          Key Statutes & Violations

          • A.R.S. § 33-1817 (1 cases)
          • CC&Rss Part 10 10.4 (1 cases)

          Representation Snapshot

          When Defending Complaints

          Top Law Firms

          • Fitzgibbons Law Offices PLC — 1 cases

          Lead Attorneys

          • David Fitzgibbons — 1 cases

          When Filing as Petitioner

          No petitioner firm data recorded.

          Case Volume by Year

          Year Cases
          2020 1

          Case Explorer







            Blue Ridge Estates Homeowner Association

            Posted on by

            Blue Ridge Estates Homeowner Association appears in 2 ADRE/OAH disputes.
            Homeowners prevailed in 0 matters while the association secured
            2 wins, leaving 0 split decisions. Explore the
            statutes, representation, and outcomes below.

            Total Cases2
            Issues Litigated2
            Homeowner Issue Wins0
            Association Issue Wins2
            Homeowner Win Rate0.0%
            Dominant RoleRespondent
            Respondent Appearances2
            Petitioner Filings0
            Last Decision2021-04-27
            Penalties AssessedNone
            Avg Penalty / CaseNone
            Filing Fees RecordedNone

            Key Statutes & Violations

            • Architectural Committee Aligned Standard 3 D (1 cases)
            • CC&Rss 3.1 A (1 cases)
            • A.R.S. § 33-1803 (1 cases)
            • CC&Rs Article X (1 cases)
            • CC&Rs 10.3 (1 cases)

            Representation Snapshot

            When Defending Complaints

            Top Law Firms

            • Resnick & Louis, P.C. — 1 cases
            • CHDB Law LLP — 1 cases

            Lead Attorneys

            • Brian C. Axt — 1 cases
            • Nicholas C. S. Nogami — 1 cases

            When Filing as Petitioner

            No petitioner firm data recorded.

            Case Volume by Year

            Year Cases
            2017 1
            2021 1

            Case Explorer







              Mesa Coronado III Condominium Association

              Posted on by

              Mesa Coronado III Condominium Association appears in 2 ADRE/OAH disputes.
              Homeowners prevailed in 1 matters while the association secured
              1 wins, leaving 0 split decisions. Explore the
              statutes, representation, and outcomes below.

              Total Cases2
              Issues Litigated4
              Homeowner Issue Wins2
              Association Issue Wins2
              Homeowner Win Rate50.0%
              Dominant RoleRespondent
              Respondent Appearances2
              Petitioner Filings0
              Last Decision2023-09-20
              Penalties AssessedNone
              Avg Penalty / CaseNone
              Filing Fees Recorded$1,000

              Key Statutes & Violations

              • A.R.S. § 33-1258 (2 cases)
              • Mciii Rules And Regulations #2 And #3 (1 cases)
              • Mciii CC&Rss 4.12 (1 cases)
              • Mciii CC&Rss 4.14 (1 cases)
              • A.R.S. §§ 33-1805 / 33-1258 (1 cases)
              • Mciii CC&Rss 4.13 (1 cases)
              • A.R.S. § 33-1250 (1 cases)
              • Bylaw Article 1.6 (1 cases)

              Representation Snapshot

              When Defending Complaints

              Top Law Firms

              • Maxwell & Morgan, P.C. — 1 cases

              Lead Attorneys

              • B. Austin Baillio — 1 cases
              • Chad M. Gallacher — 1 cases

              When Filing as Petitioner

              No petitioner firm data recorded.

              Case Volume by Year

              Year Cases
              2018 1
              2023 1

              Case Explorer







                Hilton Casitas Council Of Homeowners

                Posted on by

                Hilton Casitas Council Of Homeowners appears in 3 ADRE/OAH disputes.
                Homeowners prevailed in 2 matters while the association secured
                0 wins, leaving 1 split decisions. Explore the
                statutes, representation, and outcomes below.

                Total Cases3
                Issues Litigated4
                Homeowner Issue Wins3
                Association Issue Wins1
                Homeowner Win Rate75.0%
                Dominant RoleRespondent
                Respondent Appearances3
                Petitioner Filings0
                Last Decision2025-11-19
                Penalties Assessed$167
                Avg Penalty / Case$56
                Filing Fees Recorded$2,000

                Key Statutes & Violations

                • Article Iii 3 Of The Bylaws Of Hilton Casitas Council Of Co-owners (1 cases)
                • A.R.S. § 33-1250 (1 cases)
                • Schaefer V Pro Keanti Az2 Lp (1 cases)
                • A.R.S. § 33-1219 (1 cases)
                • A.R.S. § 33-1215 (1 cases)
                • Eli V Cro County A (1 cases)
                • London V Carrick (1 cases)
                • A.R.S. § 33-1202 (1 cases)

                Representation Snapshot

                When Defending Complaints

                Top Law Firms

                • Phillips, Maceyko & Battock, PLLC — 2 cases
                • Phillips Maceyko, and Battock PLLC — 1 cases

                Lead Attorneys

                • Emily H. Mann — 2 cases
                • Emily Mann — 1 cases

                When Filing as Petitioner

                No petitioner firm data recorded.

                Case Volume by Year

                Year Cases
                2023 1
                2024 1
                2025 1

                Case Explorer







                  Mogollon Airpark Inc

                  Posted on by

                  Mogollon Airpark Inc appears in 5 ADRE/OAH disputes.
                  Homeowners prevailed in 1 matters while the association secured
                  4 wins, leaving 0 split decisions. Explore the
                  statutes, representation, and outcomes below.

                  Total Cases5
                  Issues Litigated9
                  Homeowner Issue Wins3
                  Association Issue Wins6
                  Homeowner Win Rate33.3%
                  Dominant RoleRespondent
                  Respondent Appearances5
                  Petitioner Filings0
                  Last Decision2020-07-28
                  Penalties AssessedNone
                  Avg Penalty / CaseNone
                  Filing Fees Recorded$4,000

                  Key Statutes & Violations

                  • A.R.S. § 33-1803 (3 cases)
                  • 94 (1 cases)
                  • 46 (1 cases)
                  • 33 (1 cases)
                  • 20 (1 cases)
                  • 73 (1 cases)
                  • 75 (1 cases)
                  • 99 (1 cases)

                  Representation Snapshot

                  When Defending Complaints

                  Top Law Firms

                  • CHDB Law LLP — 5 cases

                  Lead Attorneys

                  • Gregory Stein — 5 cases
                  • Mark K. Sahl — 3 cases

                  When Filing as Petitioner

                  No petitioner firm data recorded.

                  Case Volume by Year

                  Year Cases
                  2018 3
                  2019 1
                  2020 1

                  Case Explorer







                    Rancho Del Lago Community Association

                    Posted on by

                    Rancho Del Lago Community Association appears in 3 ADRE/OAH disputes.
                    Homeowners prevailed in 1 matters while the association secured
                    2 wins, leaving 0 split decisions. Explore the
                    statutes, representation, and outcomes below.

                    Total Cases3
                    Issues Litigated3
                    Homeowner Issue Wins1
                    Association Issue Wins2
                    Homeowner Win Rate33.3%
                    Dominant RoleRespondent
                    Respondent Appearances3
                    Petitioner Filings0
                    Last Decision2023-08-11
                    Penalties AssessedNone
                    Avg Penalty / CaseNone
                    Filing Fees Recorded$1,000

                    Key Statutes & Violations

                    • CC&Rss 3.11 D 1 / Common Project Guidelines 3.11 D 1 (1 cases)
                    • A.R.S. § 33-1803 (1 cases)
                    • 3.1 D 3 Of The CC&Rss (1 cases)
                    • Appendix B 5 (1 cases)

                    Representation Snapshot

                    When Defending Complaints

                    Top Law Firms

                    • Goodman Law Group — 1 cases
                    • Brown Law Group — 1 cases
                    • Childers Hanlon 7 Hudson, PLC — 1 cases

                    Lead Attorneys

                    • Ashley N. Moscarello — 1 cases
                    • Mackenzie Hill — 1 cases
                    • Michael S. Mcleran — 1 cases

                    When Filing as Petitioner

                    No petitioner firm data recorded.

                    Case Volume by Year

                    Year Cases
                    2019 1
                    2022 1
                    2023 1

                    Case Explorer