Case Summary
| Case ID | 23F-H003-REL |
|---|---|
| Agency | ADRE |
| Tribunal | OAH |
| Decision Date | 2022-12-20 |
| Administrative Law Judge | Jenna Clark |
| Outcome | loss |
| Filing Fees Refunded | $500.00 |
| Civil Penalties | $0.00 |
Parties & Counsel
| Petitioner | Matthew E Thompson | Counsel | — |
|---|---|---|---|
| Respondent | Deer Valley Homeowners Association Inc. | Counsel | Beth Mulcahy, Esq. & Haidyn Di Lorenzo, Esq. |
Alleged Violations
Sun City West Dec CC&Rs Article 4.2(F); Deer Valley CC&Rs Articles 1.16, 6.2, 2.3, 7.1, 7.3; Deer Valley HOA Rules & Regulations ¶ 7.1 and 7.2
Outcome Summary
The Administrative Law Judge denied the petition, concluding Petitioner failed to sustain the burden of proof that the Association violated community documents by failing to replace trees on Member lots. The CC&Rs did not establish a duty for the HOA to replace homeowner trees.
Why this result: Petitioner failed to meet the burden of proof; Petitioner was not an aggrieved party; Petitioner failed to establish causation by Respondent or duty to act by Respondent; trees belong to homeowners, and the Deer Valley CC&Rs do not require the HOA to replace trees under its maintenance obligations.
Key Issues & Findings
Whether Respondent is responsible for replacing dead and/or dying trees on all Member Lots in accordance with cited community documents.
Petitioner alleged the HOA violated governing documents by failing to replace dead trees on member lots, and sought an order compelling the replacement of 59 missing trees (at a rate of 10 per year).
Orders: Petitioner’s petition is denied.
Filing fee: $500.00, Fee refunded: No
Disposition: respondent_win
- Sun City West Dec CC&Rs Article 4.2(F)
- Deer Valley CC&Rs Article 1.16
- Deer Valley CC&Rs Article 6.2
- Deer Valley CC&Rs Article 2.3
- Deer Valley CC&Rs Article 7.1
- Deer Valley CC&Rs Article 7.3
- Deer Valley HOA Rules & Regulations ¶ 7.1
- Deer Valley HOA Rules & Regulations ¶ 7.2
Analytics Highlights
- ARIZ. REV. STAT. §§ 32-2102
- ARIZ. REV. STAT. §§ 32-2199 et seq.
- ARIZ. REV. STAT. § 32-2199.05
- ARIZ. REV. STAT. §§ 32-2199(2)
- ARIZ. REV. STAT. § 32-2199.01(A)
- ARIZ. REV. STAT. § 32-2199.01(D)
- ARIZ. REV. STAT. § 32-2199.02
- ARIZ. REV. STAT. § 41-1092 et seq.
- ARIZ. REV. STAT. § 41-1092.09
- ARIZ. REV. STAT. Title 33, Chapter 16, Article 1
- Tierra Ranchos Homeowners Ass'n v. Kitchukov, 216 Ariz. 195, 165 P.3d 173 (App. 2007)
- MORRIS K. UDALL, ARIZONA LAW OF EVIDENCE § 5 (1960)
- BLACK’S LAW DICTIONARY 1220 (8th ed. 1999)